The Pepe Controversy And The Spanish Press: Are 'Marca' And 'As' Really Real Madrid's Newspapers?
It's a common belief that, while Mundo Deportivo and Sport are FC Barcelona's tabloids, the dailies Marca and As are biased in favor of Real Madrid. However, these two Madrid-based tabloids show a very different criteria from their Catalan counterparts when something bad happens to "their" team on the field.
Would a Real Madrid-supporting newspaper use the headline 'He's dead' about a player (if he wasn't actually dead)? It's always good to criticize, but Marca and As usually go too far.
Mourinho and his players were the main focus in the next day's press, and both Marca and As (and of course Sport and Mundo Deportivo) blamed Real Madrid for what happened at the end of the match.
Every Spanish journalist seemed to be worrying about the Spanish National Team, and whether they would tear apart due to infighting: these same journalists worried about how the Spanish team was going to behave in its' next game against Chile. At the end of that match, another fight broke out; the only difference was that this time, (FC Barcelona's Sergio Busquets came to (Real Madrid's) Alvaro Arbeloa's rescue while (Real Madrid's) Sergio Ramos defended (Barcelona's) Andres Iniesta from Chilean attacks.
via www.lalibretadevangaal.com
This was the reaction of the press to that incident: Marca used the headline 'One Team' on their front page, while As saw what happened as 'The Fight of Reconciliation'. It's curious how the perspective of the press changed when the Spanish players were the ones involved in the fight: from 'This better be the last time' after the Supercup game, suddenly, fighting became positive, and showed how united the team was.
Pepe walked on Messi's hand last Wednesday and the whole media exploded all over again, but nobody said a single thing about Soldado stamping on a Levante defender in Valencia's game last Thursday:
Agresión Soldado a Cabral (via Fdkn)
There's not that big of a difference...other than Soldado's passport and club.
Here's a link where you can see a video showing Real Madrid fans asking for Mourinho to leave. From an 80,000 people crowd, Marca only showed ten fans wanting Mourinho's head, and somehow draws the conclusion that Real Madrid's fan base wants the Portuguese coach to leave.
But this was not the first time that Marca has arrogantly assumed that they have the authority to bring a new coach to the team. During Manuel Pellegrini's stint with Real Madrid, Marca's cover read 'Pellegrini, get out' after the 4-0 loss in Alcorcón. But after the Liga finished with a 1-1 draw in Málaga, they crossed the line.
'Manolo, you're fired'
Madrid's fans might have been divided about Pellegrini, and it was fair to say that the team could've done better. But you could also argue that he had just completed a good campaign and that the team needed to trust him for another year. That's not the point. Marca does not have the right to demolish a coach just because they want to. They may completely control some of their readers, but they must not be in charge of the team.
Something similar might occur with Jose Mourinho this season, but many of the fans in the Bernabeu (and specially outside of it) still want him as coach. This time, however, most madridistas have realized how bad Marca and As are for the club's interests, and some have even created hashtags and a twitter account (@BoicotAsMarca) to protest their arrogant semi-journalism. We here at Managing Madrid call on these journalists to wake up and start informing--doing their real job--instead of trying to control the club with their fake-news propaganda.
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Thank you Gabe
Hasta el final, vamos Real.
by Lucas Navarrete on Jan 21, 2012 10:29 PM CET up reply actions
great post
what I also don’t get is how come they are allowed to get away with anything? Daniel Alves clothesline Callejon in same match and not a peep
It takes a man to suffer ignorance and smile
by MoLimits on Jan 21, 2012 11:14 PM CET via Android app reply actions
They've worked very well on their image.
So now they are seen as a team that never plays dirty or kicks anybody.
Hasta el final, vamos Real.
by Lucas Navarrete on Jan 21, 2012 11:18 PM CET up reply actions
Don't worry, this is changing.
Neutrals the world over are beginning to turn on Barcelona.
Editor-in-Chief of Managing Madrid
@GabeLezra
I agree with this post. There is no “Madrid Press” – it is a parasitic relationship.
What Pepe did was embarrassing and vicious but the press behave as though he stomped on someone’s face. If he hadn’t done it, the headlines might have been about Fabregas’s girly-little flick on one of the Madrid defenders. I haven’t re-watched the game but I remember the commentators finding Fabregas’s kick-out funny and losing it over Pepe.
Small correction: I seem to remember Ozil was hit in the face a couple times (once by Villa, once by Pinto), not that he hit anyone. He was definitely red-carded for losing his temper after it happened though. So was Villa. Both are banned for any future super-copa for one match. The footage should be on Youtube.
Nice blog by the way. Really first rate.
Thanks, and welcome!
Good comment, too—that whole brawl at the end of the supercopa was so hard to understand. You could barely see who was doing what.
Editor-in-Chief of Managing Madrid
@GabeLezra
Damn it I forgot – I also meant to say that an interesting point about Soldado. I think you’ll find if Pepe had stepped on a Levante player’s hand nothing would have happened either. It certainly wouldn’t be on Marca’s front page anyway.
These parasites make their living off Madrid. They probably prefer it when things are going badly.
Marca and AS are jokes
In reality most avid football followers realise that these papers are jokes because they publish fictional rubbish. We always read about Cruyff blathering on about Mourinho this and Real Madrid that but everyone (other than Barcelona) knows that he is scared of Mourinho’s magic. In truth they thrive off dissent and disharmony so they can rack up the sensational headline. Much better to read the true blogs and passionate people who tell it like it is and say when things are bad and not attempt to influence the club.
I'm ok with Marca and AS's harsh stances
I like to think that Marca and AS go out of their way to criticize Madrid because the want what’s best for the team. For example this Pepe debacle will ensure that Pepe behaves more cautiously next time because he knows that we and the Madrid press will not defend and cover-up his shameful behavior. What they said about Benzema was very harsh but at the same time it was true, Benzema was just horrible at the time and the pressure actually gave him a shock therapy wake up call.
I would much prefer our press be vicious and critique rather than salivate over, boast, conceal and devote themselves blindly to their team.
by Hes Man on Jan 22, 2012 2:54 PM CET reply actions 1 recs
Believe me.
They don’t want the best for nobody but themselves. They sell a lot when Madrid does good but also when they do bad. They only look out for the money.
Hasta el final, vamos Real.
by Lucas Navarrete on Jan 22, 2012 3:19 PM CET up reply actions
You're right
I take back what I said, Goal.com just put up an article that detailed an alleged training ground bust up between Mou/Ramos/Casillas that was printed on Marca or AS Goal.com and you’re right these papers are full of it.
I saw that to
I really don’t think that Marca/goal article was accurate. How could they possible have the entire conversation of the argument and how is it that precise. Marca is just pure tabloid garbage that just want to sell papers. I doubt that bust up happened.
Fantastic post
First time commenting and although an avid follower of this blog. The sensationalized and overtly borderline xenophobic posts (I refuse to call it news on principle) by Marca and AS are not just mere annoyance, they leave a negative impact on the team as well as taint the brand. They have sacrificed players, coaches and the truth in the alter of eye grabbing headlines and need to be called up on it. Mou’s self imposed ban is a step in the right direction.

by 




















